If coffee leaves you jittery and your focus still slips by the afternoon, you want a cup that gives you the lift without the edge. No mushroom coffee has been shown to treat anxiety, and the mushrooms in these coffees haven’t been shown to cancel caffeine’s effects. So the sensible way to choose is by the caffeine figure on each label, the mushrooms named, the price per serving and the refund terms, and that is what this guide lays out.
This site’s publisher also owns Pilly Labs, and it benefits financially when readers buy Pilly Labs products. This guide is built from published product labels, seller pages and human research; no product was taste-tested or lab-tested by us.

What the research says about caffeine, anxiety and sleep
Feeling anxious is a normal part of life. The National Institute of Mental Health draws a line between that and an anxiety disorder: for people with these disorders, “anxiety does not go away, is felt in many situations, and can get worse over time.” If that describes you, a cup of coffee is not the fix, and a doctor is the right person to talk it through with.
Caffeine is where coffee and anxiety meet. The FDA’s caffeine consumer update says that too much caffeine in children and teens can cause increased heart rate, heart palpitations, high blood pressure, anxiety, and sleep problems. That warning is written for children and teens, and it lists those symptoms for that group. The same FDA page says that if you are concerned about a condition or medication, or you are pregnant, trying to become pregnant or breastfeeding, you should talk with your health care provider about whether you need to limit caffeine.
Cleveland Clinic’s March 2023 article on mushroom coffee says it has less caffeine, which, depending on who you ask, usually helps people feel less anxious and sleep better. That is the claim to test against the number on the label. If you want the wider picture on supplements for stress and mood, our guide to natural anxiety relief supplements covers it.
Does mushroom coffee have less caffeine?
Sometimes, and only when the label gives a figure. Four Sigmatic’s Original Mushroom Coffee lists “Half-caf, 50mg” per serving. RYZE calls its coffee “less caffeine than traditional coffee” but gives no figure in its page text. Both Pilly Labs coffees say caffeine is in the cup, but neither gives a caffeine amount. Pilly’s Premium page says, “The label does not state the caffeine amount,” and its Vitality page says, “The caffeine amount is not stated.” MUD/WTR is a coffee alternative rather than coffee, and its page lists 35 mg of caffeine per serving.
The publisher of this site also owns Pilly Labs. Pilly Labs sells Vitality Mushroom Coffee and Premium Mushroom Coffee, with ingredient amounts listed on its labels, and it sits in the table below beside RYZE, Four Sigmatic and MUD/WTR, described the same way.
| Product | Preparation | Caffeine as stated | Mushroom ingredients and amounts | Serving |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| RYZE Mushroom Coffee | Powder, dissolved in hot water or milk | “Less caffeine than traditional coffee” (seller’s words); figure not in the seller’s page text | Blend of functional mushrooms; species and amounts not in the seller’s page text | 1–2 tbsp in 4–6 oz hot water or milk |
| Four Sigmatic Original Mushroom Coffee | Organic instant | 50 mg per serving (“Half-caf, 50mg”) | Lion’s mane, chaga, cordyceps, reishi and turkey tail; amounts not in the seller’s page text | 1 Tbsp in 8 fl oz hot water; 30 servings |
| MUD/WTR Original (coffee alternative) | Powder, made as a warm drink | 35 mg per serving (Original blend) | Chaga, reishi, lion’s mane and cordyceps, 560 mg each (2,240 mg of mushrooms per serving); the seller says the blend uses mushrooms and mycelium cultured on oats and/or sorghum | 30 servings per tin |
| Pilly Labs Premium Mushroom Coffee (instant) | Instant; dissolved in hot water | “The label does not state the caffeine amount” | Lion’s Mane powder 15%, Chaga powder 15%, Arabica 70% of dry mix; about 300 mg of each mushroom per 2 g serving (dry-mix arithmetic) | 1 tsp (~2 g) in 8–10 oz hot water; 27 servings |
| Pilly Labs Vitality Mushroom Coffee (ground) | Ground; brewed by drip, pour-over or French press | “The caffeine amount is not stated” | Lion’s Mane powder 5%, Chaga powder 5%, Arabica 90% of dry mix; about 500 mg of each mushroom per 10 g serving (dry-mix arithmetic) | 1 tbsp (10 g) per 8–10 oz water; 34 servings |
Two numbers in that table come from arithmetic on the labels’ percentages, not from a lab test. Pilly’s Vitality page says a dry-mix amount is not what ends up in a brewed cup, so treat the 300 mg and 500 mg figures as the amount in the dry mix. Pilly’s Premium page also says research on individual mushroom species does not predict outcomes from a finished coffee product.
So the mushrooms are not a caffeine offset. The mushrooms in these coffees haven’t been shown to cancel caffeine’s effects, which means you should plan around the caffeine figure and judge the mushrooms as a separate question.
What does the research on lion’s mane and mood actually show?
The human studies on lion’s mane test supplements and extracts rather than coffee. A double-blind study in young adults, published in Nutrients in 2023, looked at the acute and chronic effects of lion’s mane on cognitive function, stress and mood; its title calls it a pilot study. A four-week study in young women, published in Frontiers in Nutrition in 2026, tested lion’s mane alone and a lion’s mane and reishi blend on mood and wellbeing measures. The results of both are in their PubMed abstracts.
One randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study ran for 12 weeks on oral intake of Hericium erinaceus supplements. Its abstract says that on the Mini Mental State Examination alone, intake “significantly improved cognitive functions.” That result came from one test, which is the limit the abstract itself sets on it.
Reishi has its own trial. A 2024 randomized controlled trial in female college students in West Bengal, India, looked at Ganoderma lucidum (reishi) supplementation and psychological stress. A 2025 systematic review of Hericium erinaceus as a supplement covers its benefits and side effects. None of these studies tested a mushroom coffee.
If you want to compare lion’s mane studies with other options for focus, our guide to focus and attention supplements lays them side by side.
Are mushroom coffees safe, and who should skip them?
Why do I feel weird after drinking mushroom coffee?
Two possible factors are caffeine and the mushrooms themselves. The first is caffeine. The FDA says too much caffeine in children and teens can cause heart palpitations, anxiety and sleep problems. The second is the mushrooms. Cleveland Clinic says mushrooms “can sometimes cause digestive issues, especially for those who have kidney issues or trouble with grains,” and that chaga mushrooms “are high in oxalates and are known to affect and increase kidney stones.” Its dietitian suggests trying one type of mushroom powder at a time and tracking any symptoms. If digestive trouble continues, the same article suggests speaking with a healthcare provider or meeting with a dietitian.
Who should skip mushroom coffee?
- People sensitive to caffeine. Pilly’s Premium page says to avoid it in that case.
- Children, and people who are pregnant or nursing. Pilly’s Premium page says they should seek professional guidance before use, and the FDA says to talk with a provider about caffeine if you are pregnant, trying to become pregnant or breastfeeding.
- Anyone with a history of kidney stones or an oxalate-related condition. Pilly’s Premium page says to consult a healthcare provider, and Cleveland Clinic links chaga’s oxalates to kidney stones.
- Anyone taking blood thinners or medicine for blood sugar. Pilly’s Premium page says chaga may interact with blood-thinning medication and says to consult your healthcare provider before use if you take blood sugar medication.
Your prescriber or pharmacist is the right person to check any of these against the medicines you take.
Who should not drink RYZE mushroom coffee?
For RYZE, start with the general cautions for mushroom coffee, because they apply to it too. RYZE is a coffee-based drink with caffeine, so the FDA’s caution about caffeine applies: talk with a provider if you are pregnant, trying to become pregnant, breastfeeding, or concerned about a condition or medication. If the blend includes chaga, the oxalate concern applies to anyone with a history of kidney stones.
Do doctors recommend mushroom coffee?
The clearest answer comes from Cleveland Clinic’s March 2023 article. Its dietitian says, “Given the lack of research on mushroom coffee, [she] isn’t inclined to recommend it.” She suggests whole mushrooms instead, and if you still want to try a mushroom coffee, one powder at a time with symptom tracking.
What do these coffees cost, and how do refunds work?
Prices as shown on November 20, 2026. Prices and bundles change. Cleveland Clinic notes that mushroom coffee costs about double the average coffee, so it is as much a budget decision as a taste one.
- Four Sigmatic Original Mushroom Coffee: the 30-serving pack is $35.00 as the Subscribe & Save first-order price, and the one-time “Try Once” option is listed at $50.00. Recurring orders get 20% off, and the page lists a 60-day money back guarantee.
- RYZE Mushroom Coffee: the 30-serving bag shows $27 against a $50 list price. The $27 is the Black Friday sale price shown on the page, which carries a sale countdown timer. The page also lists free US shipping and a 30-day money back guarantee.
- MUD/WTR Original: a 30-serving tin is $50 one-time, or $1.67 per serving. The subscription shows $40, or $1.34 per serving, and ships every 4 weeks; the page says you can cancel any time.
- Pilly Labs Premium Mushroom Coffee: $29.99 against a $47.99 regular price, for 27 servings. U.S. shipping is $6.90, or free when your order reaches $99.
- Pilly Labs Vitality Mushroom Coffee: $29.99 against a $47.99 regular price, for 34 servings, with the same shipping terms.
Pilly’s product pages describe a 30-day return request window after delivery. To start a return, contact info@pillylabs.com.
Which one should you choose?
There isn’t one best brand for everyone. Choose the format you will drink every day, the caffeine figure you can plan around, and the price per serving.
- If you want a printed caffeine number, Four Sigmatic lists 50 mg per serving.
- If you want to step away from coffee, MUD/WTR is a coffee alternative.
- If you like a quick cup, RYZE and Pilly Labs Premium are both instant powders.
- If you like the brewing ritual, Pilly Labs Vitality is the ground option. Its caffeine figure is not stated on the page, so ask about it before you choose.
If you already feel caffeine sensitive, start with one cup and one mushroom product, and track how you feel, as Cleveland Clinic’s dietitian suggests. If you want a fuller look at what the research says about calm focus, our guide to mental health supplements sets out the options.
Before you order
- Ask Pilly Labs for the caffeine figure for its two coffees, since neither page states one.
- Confirm the current price and shipping on the product page before you pay.
- Know the return window: 30 days for Pilly Labs, 60 days for Four Sigmatic, and 30 days for RYZE.
- If you take blood thinners, blood sugar medication, or have a history of kidney stones, check with your prescriber or pharmacist before your first cup.
By the Global MH Summit Research Team